As a 2003 model, Porsche Cayenne was the right product at the right time when it was introduced in 2002. Porsche’s first four-door model, the Cayenne, despite its unlovable appearance, set new standards for how a spacious, heavy SUV could drive. Based on three generations and more than 20 years of data, we can evaluate which are the best and worst years for the Porsche Cayenne.
Porsche Cayennes are known for their durability, but repair and maintenance costs can be high. Whatever generation you own, it’s one of the best-driving SUVs ever made, if you’re prepared to accept that.
Porsche Cayenne Overview
First Generation
With two V8 engines and a 450-horsepower Turbo, the Cayenne was introduced in America for the 2003 model year. Base models weren’t that fast, but Turbos could reach 60 mph in around five seconds. In addition to automatic versions of the first Cayenne, manual versions were also available, and the vehicle surprised with its off-road capabilities. In the first generation, the Turbo S had 550 horsepower at its peak.
However, Porsche is still learning how to imbue a tall, heavy SUV with athletic driving dynamics, even though its top models are quick. Despite handling well in comparison to similar SUVs of the era, early Cayennes felt like heavy SUVs. While looks are subjective, you won’t find many people who thought the first Cayenne was beautiful.
Second Generation
The second-generation Cayenne had an interior that was similar to that in the Porsche Panamera, making it easier to warm up to immediately. It appeared smaller due to the sleeker body, but this was an optical illusion caused by the more elegant proportions. Compared to the previous model, this Cayenne lost around 400 pounds of weight, making it more agile.
New hybrid models have a combined fuel efficiency of 21 mpg, while delivering impressive acceleration with 375 horsepower combined. Plug-in hybrids were also available with the capability of driving short distances solely on electricity. It was still possible to purchase sporty GTS and Turbo models, with the Turbo S delivering as much as 563 horsepower.
Third Generation
As of the 2019 model year, the third generation of the Cayenne will be available in America, with features such as Porsche Dynamic Chassis Control with electrically adjustable anti-roll bars and rear-wheel steering, which makes it feel smaller and more athletic than previous generations.
The automatic transmission is even smoother than before, but there is no manual option for this generation. Porsche introduced the sporty-styled Cayenne Coupe in 2019 as an alternative to the BMW X6 and Mercedes-Benz GLE-Class Coupe. Turbo GT, a more recent version of the Cayenne, set a new Nurburgring SUV record thanks to its 631 horsepower.
It was announced last year that the third-generation Cayenne would be heavily facelifted with a completely new dashboard, more powerful engines, and a few new features for driver assistance. As part of the 2023 CarBuzz Awards, the latest Cayenne won the category for Family Luxury.
Best Years For The Porsche Cayenne
Overall, the Porsche Cayenne has had few complaints reported to Car Complaints over its three-generation run. Zero complaints have been recorded for the 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2017, and 2003 models. Three complaints were filed for the 2019 model year, compared to two for the 2020 model year. A great quality and reliability rating of 81 out of 100 has also been given to the latest Cayenne by J.D. Power.
NHTSA complaints about the Cayenne follow a similar pattern even though different sources can provide conflicting information. The majority of third-gen models receive zero or a small number of complaints.
NHTSA records with no recalls, investigations, or complaints for specific Cayenne models include:
Third-generation models have been on sale for less time, so older versions have accumulated more problems.
The majority of Porsche Cayenne models are safe, with 2022-2023 models apparently trouble-free so far, as well as the 2018 Cayenne (the last year of the second-generation model).
Best Porsche Cayenne Configurations
Porsche Cayenne buyers don’t always expect stellar reliability. There are a lot of things that can go wrong with this advanced luxury/performance SUV. Compared with luxury midsize SUVs, Cayenne owners visit a repair shop about 1.1 times per year for an unscheduled repair, according to Repair Pal.
The most exciting variants of this SUV can be chosen once you accept that it won’t deliver Camry-like dependability. Most Cayenne variants can be justified, but there is one we would stay away from.
The Turbos
A Cayenne Turbo is a great choice if performance is your primary concern. It would still be considered quick today if you had the first-gen model, which had 450 hp from its V8. As Porsche’s power increased over the years, including with the Turbo S E-Hybrid’s 542 horsepower, the Turbo GT set a new standard.
The latter now makes 650 horsepower and runs to 189 mph in only 3.1 seconds. It costs almost $200,000 and makes 650 horsepower. The current Turbo E-Hybrid has even more power (729 hp) and is cheaper than the GT, but it’s slower (if you call 0-60 in 3.5 seconds slow).
In 2006, the V8 Cayenne used a lot of gas (14 mpg combined), but that was just 1 mpg less than the six-cylinder Cayenne.
The GTSs
There are probably no better Cayennes than the GTS models. With sharper handling, sportier looks, and more power, they’re more appealing than the base models – without the outrageous outputs of the Turbos, which can’t be fully utilized on public roads.
First Porsche in the modern era with a GTS badge on its model name and more than 400 horsepower, the Cayenne GTS was the first Porsche with a GTS badge on its model name. I’d recommend looking for a rare first-generation manual GTS if you can find one. Cayenne S fills that role with a new V8 for the 2024 facelift instead of GTS.
The Cayenne S
Cayenne S is a good option if you want a V8 without needing extra power or wanting the higher risk factor of turbocharged V8s. As the second generation developed, power increased gradually from 335 hp to 450 hp. There is a risk of bore wear on this engine, and we would be cautious of any model that emits a knocking noise, unusual tapping, or smokes.
This variant eventually replaced the Cayenne S’s V8 with a turbocharged 3.6-liter V6, continuing Porsche’s pattern of switching engines. For the 2024 model year, a 468-hp V8 will replace the previous 2.9-liter turbocharged V6.
The Starter Cayennes
The base Cayenne was powered by a 3.2-liter VR6 with 247 horsepower, which was disappointingly underpowered. In addition, this engine had to work hard to move the Cayenne’s body, so it wasn’t much more efficient than the V8. Due to these reasons, we wouldn’t recommend it for the Cayenne.
In later years, a 3.6-liter VR6 with 296 horsepower was introduced. We found a 2011 Cayenne with a 3.6-liter VR6 selling for under $19,000 late last year. If you follow a good maintenance schedule, the VR6 can last thousands of miles.
With the third-generation Cayenne, turbocharged V6 engines were introduced that were much, much better.
Cayenne S models with naturally aspirated V8 engines can last for many years if properly maintained. Hybrids mainly delivered better performance, not exceptional gas mileage, while diesels delivered greater efficiency.
- Best & Worst Chrysler 300 Years | Years to Avoid
- Best & Worst Chrysler Pacifica Years | Years to Avoid
- Best & Worst Dodge Charger Years | Years to Avoid
- Best & Worst Dodge Ram 2500 Years | Years to Avoid
- Best & Worst Lexus RX 350 Years | YearsTo Avoid
- Worst BMW X5 Years To Avoid: Problems To Know
- Best & Worst Mazda 3 Years | Years To Avoid
Worst Years Of The Porsche Cayenne
There are 13 complaints for the 2011 Porsche Cayenne and 11 complaints for the 2004 Porsche Cayenne, according to Car Complaints. The 2011 model had the most engine problems, while the 2004 model had cooling system problems.
On the NHTSA website, we found a correlation between the 2004 Cayenne and the 2003 Cayenne S, which both had nine recalls. A fuel pump flange could crack, leading to a leak and potentially a fire for the 2003-2006 models.
There have been more than 50,000 recalls of Cayenne S and Turbo models due to this problem. The most common Cayenne problem, affecting later Cayennes around 91,000 miles, is a failing fuel pump that causes the vehicle not to start or stall.
There have also been six recalls on 2019 models (six recalls) and five recalls on 2011 models (five recalls). There was only one Cayenne Turbo recalled for loose shock absorbers in the 2019 model.
Once again, the 2004 Cayenne received the most complaints on the NHTSA website. The vehicle has 101 complaints, many of which are quite serious – there are 17 complaints about the engine and 15 about the fuel/propulsion system. Next, there are 55 complaints about the 2011 Cayenne.
In spite of the fact that the Cayenne is not bulletproof, it is important to put it into context. One model year saw 22 recalls and 327 complaints for the worst BMW X5, so this rival has suffered from more problems.
Since the 2004 and 2011 Cayennes suffered a comparatively greater number of issues and complaints than the other Cayennes, they should be avoided.
Porsche Cayenne: Most Troublesome Models
| 2004 Cayenne | 101 |
| 2011 Cayenne | 55 |
| 2006 Cayenne | 52 |
| 2011 Cayenne S | 45 |
| 2011 Cayenne S Hybrid | 45 |
| 2014 Cayenne | 43 |
| 2008 Cayenne | 41 |
Summary: Generally Great, But Be Prepared For Expensive Repairs
Despite its well-engineered design, the Porsche Cayenne offers a comfortable ride with secure handling, and can compete with many sports cars at straight lines. A quality product inside and out, it can last for many years – but at a price.
You should expect to pay a higher repair bill than you would for many similar vehicles, regardless of the model. A luxury midsize SUV requires an annual average repair cost of $1,231, which is quite a bit more than the average $807 for all luxury midsize SUVs. Maintenance costs will also be higher on more complex models with turbocharged engines and air suspensions.
When buying a used vehicle, we recommend staying clear of the most troublesome model years and ensuring the vehicle has a comprehensive service record.